WordPress Plugin: DoFollow
May 24th, 2007
Have you ever noticed that when you comment on some blogs, the search engines will pick it up as a link to your website, while on other sites it doesn’t?
That is because most blogging sites, such as WordPress, Blogger, and Typepad, all add a “NoFollow” tag to all comments, which instructs search engines to not follow the link when doing their crawls. Â
This was intended to be a good way to discourage spam and pointless commenting that doesn’t add anything to the conversation.  There is, however, an easy way for WordPress blogs to remove the “NoFollow” tag from your comments.   Simply install the DoFollow plugin. Â
Why would you do this? Currently, in order to get link credit for a comment, you will typically need to post enough to make the website’s “Top Commentators” section on the blog’s sidebar. This plugin instead rewards all commentators, including those that only leave a single comment on your website. Â
So, what is the downside?  Will you get fewer comments because people are competing for that Top Commentator spot? Probably not, but its something to consider.  Another thing to consider are the SEO ramifications. I know I have a few SEO experts that read this site.  Is this SEO suicide?  I’ve often heard it’s better to have more incoming links than outgoing links. Obviously your domain’s outgoing links will go through the roof with this plugin.  Any thoughts?










These tips are really useful for SEO, i have also found some tips forSEO.
Mujju – Looks like you found those tips on your site
I did use this plugin, but now I’ve stopped it due to those exact same SEO problems. For a new blog, I didnt want mine to look like a link farm with so many outgoing links.
Also, it would be better to have a paid dofollow system like John Chow.
Yeah, unfortunately because John is evil and he chooses to charge for it
I would do the same thing in his situation though!
How big an increase did going dofollow have on your traffic and comments?
Mlankton – I haven’t actually installed the DoFollow plugin, because I am still undecided about how I feel about it. There are several bloggers, including a few prominent ones, that are campaigning for the removal of NoFollow though.
This post was written to kind of collect people’s thoughts on this. I ended up deciding to not install the plugin. Instead, my Top Commentators plugin was adjusted to show the Top 10 instead of Top 5. This way a better link than a comment link because its on every page of the website, so people can fight to get on that list if they want some link juice.
So far, I can’t complain.
Its ironic that many bloggers talk about this but then they actually use no follow.
I think it depends on your focus. On a blog, it can only help, but if your focus is different, then maybe dofollow isn’t your best option. If your site is a portal or magazine, I don’t see why you would implement dofollow.
Bape – I couldn’t disagree more, as I don’t see any irony involved. Many bloggers feature all sorts of plugins, themes, or software that they don’t use.
Mlankton – I’ve been doing a lot of reading and studying up on SEO juice and how it works. I don’t believe that DoFollow has any positive effects, except to increase comments. Also, if you increase comments with DoFollow, they aren’t always quality comments, but rather just short blurbs like “Great post!”, “Thanks!”, etc. and they don’t really add anything to the conversation.
I think to many people value the success of their blog based on the number of comments they get, which is unforatunate. I love comments as much as the next person, but it wouldn’t bother me if I didn’t receive any for a week straight. I know, based on subscriber counts, that people are reading my stuff and thats the reason I take the time to write.
Kyle – I’ve installed the DoFollow plugin as an effort to opening my blog to commentators who wish to add to the topics discussed.
I encourage fruitful and constructive comments whereas blocking ‘blurbs’.
For the time being I prefer this method instead of sitewide links.